Aromas Para El Alma, a Costa Rica drug manufacturer, made EREWHON hand sanitizer/spray subpotent and broke manufacturing rules.
What happened
FDA inspected the Costa Rica facility from October 16 to 19, 2023. It found the company changed the ethanol used in EREWHON HAND SANITIZER and EREWHON ANTIBACTERIAL SPRAY without updating the formula, so some batches had less ethanol than labeled and were released. FDA also found incomplete batch records, missing component identity testing, and inadequate quality-unit oversight.
What FDA found
The company did not establish adequate written production and control procedures for adding components, and it released batches formulated below the labeled ethanol strength.
21 CFR 211.101Batch production and control records lacked complete instructions, including critical steps/parameters and component weights or volumes.
21 CFR 211.188The company did not adequately test each component lot, including ethanol, for identity and conformity with purity, strength, and quality specifications before use.
21 CFR 211.84(d)(1) and (2)The quality control unit did not ensure adequate finished-product testing and specifications, a stability program, or written responsibilities.
21 CFR 211.22; 211.165(a),(b); 211.137(a); 211.22(d)EREWHON ANTIBACTERIAL SPRAY was marketed as an unapproved new drug and its directions allowed spraying the whole body, beyond the conditions for over-the-counter antiseptic rubs.
FD&C Act sections 505(a), 301(d), and 505G(a)(3)The labels featured inactive oils prominently, making the products misbranded, and EREWHON ANTIBACTERIAL SPRAY did not comply with section 505G.
FD&C Act sections 502(a) and 502(ee)
What FDA wants
FDA tells the company to correct the violations promptly and respond in writing within 15 working days with supporting documents, including a full U.S. distribution reconciliation, testing/recall plans, updated formulation and validation, batch records, component controls, and quality-unit remediation. FDA also recommends a qualified consultant and a six-system audit.
Who should pay attention
- brands that buy or distribute EREWHON hand sanitizer or spray
- U.S. retailers and consumers using hand sanitizers
- contract manufacturers that change ethanol suppliers or strengths
This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.