FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Battle Creek Co-op/CHS, LLC dba Progressive Nutrition

High riskIssued Aug 14, 2023Posted Feb 13, 2024Division of Human and Animal Food Operations West II

Progressive Nutrition's cattle feed contained excess urea linked to 17 cattle deaths, with preventive-control and medicated-feed violations.

What happened

A state agriculture inspector working under FDA contract inspected the Norfolk, NE animal feed plant on January 25, 31, and February 15, 2023, as a follow-up to the firm's required food-safety report after a complaint that 17 cattle died after eating its non-medicated feed. A sample of "PN 16-8-12 Mineral R-1G" lot # M217160 found too much non-protein nitrogen as urea, making the feed injurious to cattle, and the firm recalled that lot and lot # M217170. The inspection also found missing hazard analysis for urea and mycotoxins, shared ingredient bins that allowed urea carryover, and medicated-feed failures in drug assays and inventory records.

What FDA found

  1. The hazard analysis did not identify nutrient toxicity from urea or mycotoxins (DON, fumonisin, aflatoxin) as known or reasonably foreseeable hazards.

    21 CFR 507.33(a)
  2. Bulk storage bins were not kept clean or dedicated, and urea left in a bin contaminated limestone used in the recalled feed.

    21 CFR 507.19(a)
  3. The firm did not investigate or correct medicated feed test results that were far above label amounts: lasalocid at 183 g/ton vs 100 g/ton and monensin at 803 g/ton vs 400 g/ton.

    21 CFR 225.58(d)
  4. The firm did not perform the required three periodic drug assays in 2022 for feeds made with Aureo S 700 and Corid 25%.

    21 CFR 225.58(b)(1)
  5. The daily drug inventory records did not record lot changes for Aureo S 700, Aureomycin 90, or Bovatec 91.

    21 CFR 225.42(b)(6)
  6. The firm did not compare the actual amount of drug used with the theoretical amount each production day.

    21 CFR 225.42(b)(7)

What FDA wants

FDA asks the firm to respond in writing within 15 working days with the specific steps taken to correct the violations, how recurrence will be prevented, and supporting documents. If corrections cannot be completed in that time, the firm must explain the delay and give a completion date.

Who should pay attention

  • livestock producers who feed cattle minerals
  • animal feed manufacturers that use urea or shared ingredient bins
  • medicated feed mills and their drug suppliers

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. King Farm

    King Farm's horse feed held fumonisin up to 36.1 ppm; FDA ties it to at least 30 horse deaths.

    High risk
  2. Livestock Nutrition Center

    Livestock Nutrition Center made non-medicated animal feed contaminated with monensin, killing animals; FDA found preventive control failures.

    High risk
  3. Hi-Pro Feeds, LLC

    Hi-Pro Feeds made medicated goat feed linked to goat deaths; FDA cited missing urea hazard controls and late report.

    High risk
  4. Appleton City Feed Service LLC

    FDA warned Appleton City Feed Service, a Missouri medicated feed mill, of pest, cross-contamination and drug-combination risks in animal feed.

    High risk