FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Empacadora Bilbo S.A. DBA Bilbosa

High riskIssued Feb 9, 2024Posted Feb 20, 2024Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition

FDA warns Ecuadorian seafood processor Bilbosa over seafood safety plan gaps for histamine and C. botulinum.

What happened

FDA inspected the seafood processing facility in Montecristi, Manabi, Ecuador, on July 27-28, 2023, and issued a Form 483 listing inspection observations. The company responded on August 11 and October 13, 2023, with corrective actions and an updated seafood HACCP plan dated August 8, 2023. FDA evaluated the responses and said serious problems remained: the plan did not list a cold-storage control point to prevent histamine formation and had inadequate monitoring and corrective actions for histamine and C. botulinum hazards.

What FDA found

  1. The seafood safety plan did not identify the cold-storage step as a point where the company must prevent histamine formation.

    21 CFR 123.6(a) and (c)(2)
  2. At the receiving control point, the plan did not say how many fish would be checked by histamine test, sensory exam, and internal temperature measurement.

    21 CFR 123.6(c)(4)
  3. For the packaged frozen product control point, visual checking was not adequate to control C. botulinum growth and toxin formation; FDA said to examine a representative number of labeled finished packages and include safe-handling labels.

    21 CFR 123.6(c)(4)
  4. Corrective actions for the receiving control point did not say how the company would fix the cause of histamine test, sensory, or temperature deviations.

    21 CFR 123.7(b)
  5. A corrective action at another control point did not address the cause of the deviation to prevent it from happening again.

    21 CFR 123.7(b)

What FDA wants

FDA tells the company to respond in writing within 15 working days with specific corrective steps, a revised seafood HACCP plan, and five consecutive days of completed monitoring records for five production date codes. If it cannot finish all corrections in 15 days, it must explain the delay and when remaining violations will be corrected.

Who should pay attention

  • U.S. importers and buyers of frozen raw fish from Ecuador
  • seafood processors using cold storage and receiving checks for histamine-forming fish
  • brands selling frozen fish in plastic bags that need safe-handling labels

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. Ocean Pride Seafood, Inc.

    FDA warned Ocean Pride Seafood that its ready-to-eat seafood was adulterated (unsafe under law) due to missing seafood safety (HACCP) controls and insanitary conditions.

    High risk
  2. Star Ocean Wholesale Foods, Inc.

    FDA warns Star Ocean Wholesale Foods over missing checks for imported fermented fish sauce.

    High risk
  3. South Asian Food Inc.

    South Asian Food Inc. lacked seafood HACCP import verification and pest controls for imported dried seafood.

    High risk
  4. AF Import & Wholesale Co

    FDA warned Houston seafood importer AF Import & Wholesale for missing written verification that its imported fish was processed safely.

    High risk