FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Old Europe Cheese, Inc.

High riskIssued Mar 17, 2023Posted Apr 4, 2023Division of Human and Animal Food Operations East VI

Old Europe Cheese's ready-to-eat Brie and Camembert were tied to a six-state Listeria outbreak and made under insanitary conditions.

What happened

FDA inspected the ready-to-eat cheese plant in Benton Harbor, Michigan, from September 13 to October 6, 2022, with Michigan agriculture officials after a multistate Listeria monocytogenes outbreak. CDC reported six illnesses in six states and five hospitalizations, and FDA said an environmental swab from a floor hole matched the outbreak strain. The company recalled Brie, Camembert, and Baked Brie and suspended production; FDA cited insanitary conditions and failures in the food-safety rules known as CGMP and preventive controls.

What FDA found

  1. FDA said the hazard analysis wrongly concluded that Listeria contamination after pasteurization did not need a preventive control, even though the RTE cheese was exposed to the environment after pasteurization.

    21 CFR 117.130(a)(1); 21 CFR 117.135(c)(3)
  2. FDA said the hazard analysis did not require a process control for pathogen growth in cooler storage, and records showed temperatures of 51.2°F to 53.1°F without documented corrective action.

    21 CFR 117.130(a)(1); 21 CFR 117.135(c)(1); 21 CFR 117.160
  3. FDA said ingredients added after pasteurization, such as spices, had no kill step and the company lacked a required supply-chain program and annual onsite audits for Salmonella risk.

    21 CFR 117.405(a)(1); 21 CFR 117.430(b)
  4. FDA found sanitation procedures were not followed: employees handled RTE brie after touching unclean surfaces without washing, a clean-in-place vat was not fully filled, molds had food residue, pre-operation checks were missed, and environmental swabs were not collected as scheduled.

    21 CFR 117.135(a)
  5. FDA observed a hose spray hit the floor and then a cheese molding machine, which was used for brie without further cleaning.

    21 CFR 117.35(a)
  6. FDA found condensation and dark stains on ceilings and pipes above exposed RTE cheese and food-contact molds, creating a drip contamination risk.

    21 CFR 117.20(b)(4)

What FDA wants

FDA tells the company to complete and document its corrective actions--root cause investigation, facility repairs, revised food safety plan, and sanitation/environmental monitoring procedures--and provide additional information. The provided letter does not state a response deadline; FDA says it will evaluate adequacy once actions are complete and verify them at its next inspection.

Who should pay attention

  • retailers and brands selling Brie or Camembert made by contract manufacturers
  • RTE food plants with post-pasteurization exposure
  • quality teams responsible for Listeria environmental monitoring and sanitation

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. La Cabana Food Distributing, Inc.

    FDA found Listeria in La Cabana Food Distributing's ready-to-eat salsa plant and cited sanitation and hazard analysis failures.

    High risk
  2. Rama Food Manufacture Corp.

    FDA warns Rama Food Manufacture after inspections found insanitary conditions and preventive-control failures at its California ready-to-eat rice noodle plants.

    High risk
  3. Lewis Sausage Company Inc.

    FDA found Salmonella and Listeria in contract-made pet food from Lewis Sausage and says its pathogen controls are inadequate.

    High risk
  4. Dreyer’s Grand Ice Cream, Inc.

    FDA warns Dreyer’s Grand Ice Cream over Listeria and sanitation failures in frozen RTE ice cream.

    High risk