FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Primal Pet Foods, Inc.

High riskIssued Feb 21, 2023Posted Mar 14, 2023Division of Human and Animal Food Operations West V

FDA warned Primal Pet Foods after an inspection found pathogen and nutrient control failures in raw pet food, following a Listeria recall.

What happened

FDA inspected Primal Pet Foods' Fairfield, California pet food plant from July 14 through October 11, 2022, prompted by a Class 1 recall (the most serious kind) of Raw Frozen Primal Patties for Dogs Beef Formula, lot W10068709, after Listeria monocytogenes was found in an FDA surveillance sample collected from retail on May 24, 2022. The company's own records showed 49 finished cat and dog food products tested positive for Listeria monocytogenes or Salmonella between August 2021 and August 2022. FDA also found that vitamin D and thiamine testing did not reliably catch high vitamin D or low thiamine before product shipped.

What FDA found

  1. The company's preventive controls for pathogens did not work: 49 finished products tested positive for Listeria or Salmonella, and a retail sample of its dog food caused a Class 1 recall.

    21 CFR 507.34(a)(1)
  2. The company decided vitamin D and thiamine were hazards but relied on testing that was inadequate, and it shipped product before lab results came back, including a lot with vitamin D3 at 3,410 IU/kg and a cat food with thiamine at 3.96 mg/kg against an AAFCO minimum of 5.6 mg/kg.

    21 CFR 507.33(c)(1)
  3. The study offered to prove a probiotic controls Salmonella in freeze-dried raw beef did not show it works, used methods unsuitable for a high-probiotic sample, and did not address E. coli O157:H7 or Listeria.

    21 CFR 507.47(a)
  4. After the recall, the company did not evaluate other product made on the same date and line, and four finished lots tested positive for pathogens after its corrective actions.

    21 CFR 507.42(b)(1)(ii) and 507.42(b)(2)

What FDA wants

FDA asks the company to write back within 15 working days describing the specific steps taken to correct each violation and prevent recurrence, with supporting documentation, or explain why more time is needed and when the work will be finished.

Who should pay attention

  • pet owners who feed raw or freeze-dried diets
  • retailers and distributors selling raw pet food
  • other raw and freeze-dried pet food manufacturers

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. Lewis Sausage Company Inc.

    FDA found Salmonella and Listeria in contract-made pet food from Lewis Sausage and says its pathogen controls are inadequate.

    High risk
  2. Dreyer’s Grand Ice Cream, Inc.

    FDA warns Dreyer’s Grand Ice Cream over Listeria and sanitation failures in frozen RTE ice cream.

    High risk
  3. Raaw Energy LLC

    FDA: Raaw Energy's frozen raw dog food contained Salmonella, Listeria and Campylobacter and was made under insanitary conditions.

    High risk
  4. Waves and Wine, Inc.

    FDA warns Waves and Wine, a California raw pet food maker, over Listeria in its beef pet foods and inadequate food safety controls.

    High risk