FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Ridley USA, Inc. dba Hubbard Feeds, Inc.

High riskIssued Aug 2, 2022Posted Aug 23, 2022Office of Human and Animal Foods West Division II

FDA warns Hubbard Feeds after sheep feed recall over elevated copper and preventive-control failures at Kansas feed mill.

What happened

FDA inspected Hubbard Feeds' animal food feed mill in Beloit, KS, from February 14 through 24, 2022, as a follow-up to a voluntary Class I recall of Blueprint Lamb Grower 16% B30 sheep food. The recall followed elevated copper; the letter says two lots sampled under the company's release program had copper at 38.1 ppm and 31.3 ppm, above the 15 ppm maximum tolerable level for sheep food. FDA found significant violations of hazard analysis and risk-based preventive controls rules for animal food.

What FDA found

  1. The company did not sufficiently assess how likely elevated copper was without a preventive control; its prerequisite cleanout and flushing program did not reduce that risk.

    21 CFR 507.33(c)(1)
  2. The hazard analysis for nutrient deficiency or toxicity in macro ingredients was incomplete, with severity, probability, risk assessment, and preventive-control decisions left blank.

    21 CFR 507.33(a)
  3. The company's proposed new preventive control would catch bad product before distribution rather than significantly minimize or prevent the hazard as required.

    21 CFR 507.3

What FDA wants

FDA tells the company to respond in writing within 15 working days with specific corrective steps, an explanation of how recurrence will be prevented, and related documentation. FDA also asks the company to identify the root cause of the excess copper and explain equipment failures and retraining.

Who should pay attention

  • animal feed manufacturers that run shared equipment
  • sheep and livestock feed brands
  • companies relying on prerequisite programs for carryover control

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. Quantum Star LLC

    FDA found Quantum Star LLC imported pig ears contaminated with Salmonella without an FSVP for its animal foods.

    High risk
  2. J&B Food Consulting

    J&B Food Consulting lacked a Foreign Supplier Verification Program for imported pet treats; some samples had Salmonella.

    High risk
  3. Best Buy Bones, Inc.

    Best Buy Bones pet treats were found with Salmonella and serious animal-food safety and CGMP violations.

    High risk
  4. JZ Wholesale, Inc.

    FDA warned JZ Wholesale after finding widespread rodent and insect contamination in food at its Fort Smith, Arkansas warehouse.

    High risk