FDA Brief

Warning letters Food

FDA warning letter to

Ya Ya Foods USA, LLC

High riskIssued Sep 24, 2024Posted Oct 15, 2024Division of Human and Animal Food Operations West IV

FDA warned Ya Ya Foods USA that its aseptic oat milk made in Ogden, Utah, was adulterated after an inspection found processing deviations.

What happened

FDA inspected the company's low-acid canned food facility at 450 Depot Drive, Ogden, UT, from May 13 to May 16, 2024, covering aseptically processed and packaged low-acid oat milk beverages. Investigators found steam seal and steam barrier temperatures dropping below critical limits during production of several Oatly oat milk batches, monitoring and record review gaps, and temperature charts too coarse to show whether scheduled process temperatures were met. FDA also found finished product released with ATP test results above the company's own release limit, without justification that the product was commercially sterile.

What FDA found

  1. Steam seal and steam barrier temperatures fell below the critical limits during production, and the company did not identify these as deviations from the scheduled process.

    21 CFR 113.89
  2. The company did not record measurements often enough to show that steam seals and barriers on the aseptic surge tank and equipment were working properly during processing.

    21 CFR 113.40(g)(1)(ii)(E)
  3. The temperature recording charts were scaled so broadly that they could not show whether the required process temperatures were reached for several batches.

    21 CFR 113.40(g)(1)(i)(B)(1)
  4. A qualified plant management representative did not document review of aseptic filling critical factors within one working day and before release for distribution.

    21 CFR 113.100(b)
  5. Finished product was released with ATP test results above the company's established limit, without justification that the product was commercially sterile.

    21 CFR 117.80(a)(2)

What FDA wants

Within 15 working days, the company must write to FDA describing each corrective step taken and include supporting documentation; if actions are not complete, it must explain the delay and when they will be done. FDA also asked for an update on the plant expansion and its ability to supply enough steam during aseptic processing, and recommended a Process Authority review of released lots with high ATP results.

Who should pay attention

  • brands that contract-manufacture aseptic or low-acid beverages at this plant
  • co-packers and beverage companies using aseptic surge tanks and steam barriers
  • retailers and distributors selling the affected oat milk products

This is a summary. Read the original letter on fda.gov.

Similar letters to other companies

  1. Bo Wah Enterprises Inc

    Bo Wah Enterprises lacked required supplier checks for imported yam, mushroom, and sesame paste.

    Medium
  2. Fil-Bay Import, Inc.

    Fil-Bay Import lacked required foreign supplier safety plans for many imported foods and canned-food processing checks.

    High risk
  3. H2 BEV, LLC and H2 RENU, INC

    FDA warns H2 BEV and H2 RENU over unregistered acidified hydrogen beverages with unmonitored pasteurization and drug claims.

    High risk
  4. Delight Distribution Inc.

    Delight Distribution lacked required checks on imported foods, including canned chickpeas, FDA says.

    Medium